An unpopular opinion from an unpopular perspective

This might just be another voice that gets lost in the noise, a whisper against a backdrop of indifference. I’m usually not one to write about current events that don't directly impact me. It’s not that I lack opinions; it’s more that I often feel expressing them doesn’t make much difference. But, I say this now for some reason - maybe because, I too am a woman and another human being with memories that come rushing back to me in these burning days!

Skipping the obvious details of where this might be coming from, let’s rewind a few months to when I was conducting fieldwork for my doctoral research.  It was a typical day of data collection and conversations when I received news that my flatmate was in distress. After much hesitation, she revealed that she had been kidnapped that morning, with an attempted assault. The shockwaves of this revelation were profound; no one can truly grasp the depth of her trauma. What followed was vulnerability and risk assessment among ourselves to mend our ways. The concerned officials had already warned us to be alert and careful - they had traced who the culprit was, and found out that he was a psychopath. Given that he had threatened and scared the victim against raising any complaint, we were alerted that he could have been tracking us already... or not - they didn't know; he might be following those around the victim... or not - they didn't know; the culprit might call any of us to threaten... or not - they didn't know. But we were to be alert - against what exactly, we didn't know!

From changing my place of residence in a field that was already new and largely alien to me, to not venturing to my target regions alone... everything was considered. There was point where I was told that I should not worry much - that, I was overthinking! Since the culprit wouldn't be benefitted by harming me, I could be free. Yet, contrastingly, every time I would step out, I would be alerted to steer from any car that might stop anywhere near me... or to return before it was dark and keep all 4 of my associates informed of my whereabouts continuously. There were 4 instances when a vehicle stopped by me, and I swear I had my soul about to jump out! Not to claim that I was being followed - now, I didn't know!

What is my point? We could try being moderately armed and trained in martial arts, but that still doesn't protect us. We could try being extra vigilant and think in thousand different directions, and we would be tagged overthinkers or feminists (also, I don't know how is that problematic or bad!). We could be with someone we trust our safety with - physical, mental, emotional - and that doesn't guarantee safety for us.

I don’t claim to have solutions or answers to ensuring safety. I know many men I deeply respect for their integrity. But even as I see the value in the previous story I’ve shared, it feels like a temporary fix (and again, it is truly something against absurd advisories women are given - "behave gracefully" my foot!)

In my view, the root of the problem(s) is deeply entrenched in so many areas. We frequently overlook situations that seem trivial but are significant if addressed in the moment. Abuse doesn’t emerge overnight; it is nurtured through a cycle of conditioning. We’ve all witnessed instances where children are exposed to inappropriate language or songs, or where boys are told not to cry because it’s a sign of weakness (to be specific: don't cry like a girl!). These seemingly small interactions contribute to the development of abusive behaviours. When we dismiss verbal and emotional abuse as justifiable due to stress, we normalize abusive behaviour and perpetuate a culture where men believe they can act out and play victims when someone holds them responsible for the problems that they created.

Psychopath or not, overthinking isn’t a choice; it’s a defensive reaction to perceived threats. I know someone who was molested and nearly kidnapped as a 7 year old child. To stay safe, girls were taught to avoid strangers, dress modestly, and conform to a myriad of other restrictions. Yet, if boys were equally educated on respect and emotional regulation, the dynamics could shift dramatically. If only boys were taught to 'behave'; if only they were told to not to hurl abuses meaninglessly when angry, but be unapologetically vulnerable and process their emotions; if only they were warned: "if you are stepping out after 7.00pm, be 'careful' of your moves... don't disrespect anyone, behave 'gracefully', conduct yourself 'respectfully'"; if only boys were not sent out and away in the much famed 8th Grade, when the so-called specialist would be invited to enlighten 'girls' about menstruation - if only the focus were on nurturing respect and empathy from an early age rather than reinforcing outdated taboos.

An unpopular opinion from an unpopular perspective: the issues we face today are equally a part of a broader "mental health pandemic" (as my friend calls it). Consider the adage often seen on school walls: “Your beliefs become your thoughts, your thoughts become your words, your words become your actions, your actions become your habits, your habits become your values, and your values become your destiny.” The researcher's urge to clarify - I am not a Gandhian, but this quote fits rightly. The chain from beliefs to destiny is fueled by emotions, which dictate the intensity of these issues. An unpopular opinion from an unpopular perspective...

-Minty

Disclaimer: The views expressed in this blogpost (shared as images/stories on WA/IG) are the writer’s personal opinions, shaped by individual experiences and reflecting a personal perspective. These opinions are not supported by scientific or academic sources. The writer recognizes that others may have different viewpoints, which are valued and respected. Additionally, please note that any form of reproduction of this material; including quoting, screenshotting, sharing, or any other kind of dissemination is not permitted without the writer’s explicit written consent. Your understanding is appreciated.

Comments

Popular posts from this blog

Excerpt on the Unlikeable Era

Princeton Girl's Random Picks

The day my belly broke...